I've been mulling over a recent contretemps between bloggers David Sirota and Nate Silver discussed a few days ago by our friends at Donkeylicious and trying to decide whether it merited further discussion or should be dismissed as just another juvenile pissing match on the left side of the cyber-sandbox. I've come down on the side of writing about it because I think much that Silver contributed to the "debate" actually needs to be slapped down pretty hard.
Let me first say I am surprised that this was my reaction Like many people I became an enormous fan of fivethirtyeight.com during the election and was consistently impressed by Silver's statistical and analytical skills. He is obviously an exceptionally bright guy and seemed to handle his new found fame as the campaign wore on with great grace I'm not a regular reader of Sirota despite sharing what strikes me as a pretty similar ideological world view. I've always found him a bit too abrasive, a not terribly captivating writer, and more of an aggressive self-promoter than I find aesthetically pleasing. Given all of this, I started reading about this little battle over the appropriate direction of the left (very broadly speaking) with a presumption that Silver would have it right and Sirota wrong.
Silver begins by describing two forms of "progressivism", one which he characterizes as "rational" and the other as "radical" (not that that isn't tipping the debate from the get go) -- when the positions on the further end of the American left are placed in opposition to the "rational" I think it is pretty clear where things are going. Essentially Nate posits a world in which people of the more moderate center-left are empirical, analytical, expert-driven, flexible and pragmatic. Those further out on the ideological left are assigned a series of contradictory attributes (both cynical and pessimistic yet advocating a politics that is transformative), but the ultimate quality he ascribes to lefter elements is a kind of reflexively confrontational demagoguery.
Recent Comments